Thursday 13 July 2017

Midnight Special

Midnight Special feels like a much older movie than it is. In fact it feels a lot like Close Encounters of the Third Kind. There are some obvious structural similarities: that it is a road trip; that it is focused on a single man driven by desires the viewer does not fully understand; that the government is at once both ignorant of what is happening and a sinister antagonist; that the driving emotional pull is of a young child in peril; that geographic coordinates are a critical plot device; that the mysterious other is, in the end, benign; that the finale features a big special effect sequence and raises as many questions as it answers.

There is something else as well. There is a sense of wonder.

A sense of wonder is something that has been missing from films of late. It makes the occasional appearance: in Gareth Edward's Monsters, the Forest God in Guillermo del Toro's Hellboy II. The reason is no mystery. For a movie to have a sense of wonder it must be about something wonderful, something that does not exist in the ordinary world, ergo something created by special effects - but SFX are no longer wonderful. With affordable CGI everything becomes possible and so nothing is special. A whole city is levitated in Avengers: Age of Ultron and it is exciting, and supplies a strong sense of peril, but it is never wondrous.

When, in Jurassic Park, Sam Neil fell to knees in awe at seeing real live dinosaurs we were on our knees with him, equally amazed. It was just two years after we'd seen what digital effects were capable of in Terminator 2, just a year since they were considered inherently amazing enough to hang a whole film off in Lawnmower Man. It felt like the start of a new era but it was also the end of one. Three years earlier the creators of Star Trek V: The Final Frontier (not the greatest Star Trek) were so impressed by a light show they thought it would make a believable stand-in for God. Two years later in Independence Day nobody dropped to their knees in awe at the alien spaceships arriving, they pranged their cars as if it was giant wonderbra billboards descending through the clouds. Effects weren't magic anymore, at least not to filmmakers, and nobody would be truly amazed by them ever again.

So what makes Midnight Special so different?

It's not the effects. The glowing eyes are nothing that could not have been created with late eighties technology, and while done far better with CGI, the overall effect of the city at the end could have been achieved with matt paintings and miniatures.

The difference is primarily the realism, and also the mystery. Both are present from the get go, two characters barely speaking as they strip cardboard from a motel window and load guns into a bag. It's clear that the film is going to value genuine behaviour over explaining what is going on. The realism really hits though when the ranch is raided, the viewer expects it to be Waco but it is far from it. Everybody cooperates with the FBI. The FBI have to wade through interviews with everybody. It is so realistic it is almost boring.

In fact, for the first half of the movie it is only the mystery that keeps you hooked. What is special about the boy? What is the relationship between the father and his friend? Where are they heading? What happens if they are caught? By the time these start being answered you are hooked on the characters, which have been revealed slowly, and are doubly strong because of that.

Notice too how the main antagonists come to some sort of a sticky end, either arrested or perhaps even shot, but we never see it. The film is relentlessly focused on Alton and the people looking after him. It doesn't care about bad guys getting their comeuppance, this is a fantastic story but it is firmly set in the real world and you nobody gets that sort of neat satisfying end.

Consequently, by the finale the viewer is right there with characters wanting to know the answers, and equally as amazed when they are revealed. It is the mystery we came for but the realism that sold it. An invisible city covering the Gulf Coast would be no big deal in Avengers, but in a movie where everybody has looked and acted like a real person for two hours, it's huge.

And because of this the film can't tell us everything, can't wrap it up pat, or the spell would be broken. You're led to the possibility that the Alton is an angel but the reveal of the city, less heavenly towers than sci-fi brutalism, like a radical concept sketch for the South Bank Centre, muddies even that water.

In the end you're left standing there right with Alton's mother, wondering what just happened.